3 Transparency Habits That Serve Self-Storage Investors Every Time

By Kateri Foley, Director of Growth & Marketing

Twenty years ago, I chose a different path than the stereotypical salesy approach that gives reps a bad reputation. 

I realized I never truly “had a deal” to offer clients: 

  • no canned pitches
  • no one-size-fits-all solutions

Instead of spinning things or avoiding transparency, I built my approach on honesty. If a client came to me with a better deal on a project, I would tell them why I couldn’t match the price, explain what elements contributed to that difference, and, if I could, tell them what to ask the other company to ensure they wouldn’t get nickeled and dimed later. It often resulted in my clients moving forward with me regardless of price because of the trust we’d built.

Throughout my career, every project I led was entirely custom, filled with variables and room for error. What set successful relationships apart wasn’t perfection. It was quality, transparent communication and authenticity, even when things didn’t go as planned.

That mindset carried me from my earliest professional role as a Sales Executive at Hatteras to Regional Director of Programming for Parkway Property Investments, where a transparent approach led to 454% growth in client engagement. Now, ten months in, I’m honored to be part of the exceptional team at Hearthfire Holdings. 

Together we design a unique investor experience rooted in trust, clarity, and shared values.

Why the Perfect Pitch Is Dead

In an industry fueled by metrics, admitting uncertainty is often seen as weakness. But I’ve found that being honest and saying, “I don’t know yet, but I’ll find out” is far more powerful than spin.

Whether planning city-wide events for the City of Houston, managing all retail graphics for the 2017 and 2018 Super Bowls, or executing hundreds of tenant experiences at Parkway, my success was never defined by flawless execution. It was proactive communication, early issue flagging, solution-driven thinking, and the humility to say, “I’ll find out.”

When Transparency Turns Disaster Into Trust

One of my most memorable failures was many years ago at Hatteras, but it remains one of my most valuable lessons. 

I landed the Foot Locker account. I managed their national mailings around school holidays. These campaigns triggered significant increases in new shoe purchases. Our spring mailing included over 2.5 million pieces of mail with coupons that were supposed to be dropped in phases nationally following school spring breaks. 

Someone in production mistakenly released all 2.5+ million pieces at once. 

Customers at Foot Locker were trying to redeem coupons, but the coupon codes weren’t active yet because we were supposed to stagger them. Understandably, my client was very upset, as were his superiors. This was such a major mistake that we had to meet with several members of the Foot Locker C-suite to explain what happened. 

Prior to our meeting, they said they wanted us to reimburse them for the whole project, plus revenue lost due to our error. This was a huge amount of money for an independent printing company. My executive team and I went into the meeting, apologized, explained exactly how it happened, took full ownership, and outlined how we would prevent this from happening again, should we be given the opportunity to continue to work with them. 

We proposed building fenced areas to stage their projects, similar to what we did for our pharmaceutical clients who have strict sensitivity and distribution rules.

After much communication, they calmed down significantly. They said they understood that a company of our size couldn’t afford to reimburse for revenue lost, and some of them, having family members running smaller companies, could relate to our situation. We ended up keeping the business and entering into an agreement where the project cost would be discounted across the next three mailings rather than directly reimbursed.

It ended up being an incredible win. 

They appreciated our transparency about exactly what happened, our willingness to invest in systemic improvements to prevent future mistakes, and our complete ownership of the error. What could have been a relationship-ending disaster became a trust-building moment that strengthened our partnership.

I share this story because it aligns with the investor-centric approach we take at Hearthfire Holdings. 

Just as I didn’t try to minimize the Foot Locker mistake or deflect responsibility, we don’t sugarcoat market realities or hide behind industry jargon when communicating with our investors. When market conditions shift, when a project faces unexpected challenges, or when we need to pivot strategy, our investors hear about it directly and immediately. They understand not just what happened, but why it happened, what we’re doing about it, and how we’re preventing similar issues in the future. 

This level of transparency doesn’t just preserve relationships during difficult times, it deepens them. Our investors know they’re getting the complete picture, not just the highlights reel.

Sponsorship vs. Partnership: The Hearthfire Difference

What drew me to Hearthfire wasn’t the deals themselves. 

It was the company’s commitment to its mission. At Hearthfire, we don’t just sponsor projects—we partner with investors.

Our culture of trust, values alignment, and legacy creation inspires me every day. In my role, I’m not simply reporting numbers. I’m working to shape investor events and communications that foster genuine relationships with our investor community.

3 Transparency Habits That Work Every Time

  1. Lead With Context Rather than just presenting conclusions, set the stage: what’s happening in your market, why it matters, how it affects the portfolio or clients, and what is being done about it.
  2. Own Mistakes Quickly From Hatteras to Hearthfire, I’ve learned that honesty builds trust. Admitting and addressing errors early prevents bigger issues and deepens credibility.
  3. Champion Value, Not Just Returns Hearthfire has never attracted investors based solely on projected returns. Relationships are built on expertise, consistency, and strategic thinking. It’s been our experience that investors choose partners who demonstrate deep market knowledge, transparent communication, and proven track records over whoever promises the highest returns.

Voices That Validate the Approach

The belief that transparency, thoughtful planning, and human-centered communication drive long-term results isn’t just theory. It’s been affirmed in practice by leaders I’ve worked with.

Matt Mooney, COO at Parkway Property Investments, reflected on how a relationship-first approach led to real results: “Our capital constraints post-COVID meant we had to find value outside of capital improvements. Kateri’s programming, both virtual and in-person, received rave reviews from decision-makers at our largest multinational tenants. Her efforts directly impacted leasing, retention, and tenant satisfaction.”

This reflection doesn’t spotlight an individual. It affirms a process that is:

  • proactive
  • transparent, and
  • deeply committed to long-term trust. 

It’s this same approach we bring to every investor relationship at Hearthfire Holdings.

The Compound ROI of Transparency

Trust isn’t just a feel-good factor. It’s hard currency. 

Clients who understand the full picture remain confident during volatility, refer others more freely, and recognize that the value is in the process, not just the output.

Over time, that trust compounds into loyalty, premium positioning, and sustained investment success.

Building Legacies Through Honest Partnerships

Looking back across two decades, it’s not the flawless projects I remember. It’s the relationships that weathered storms with honesty and clarity. Words like “integrity,” “never let me down,” and “tenacity” aren’t about perfection. 

They’re about trust.

Transparency isn’t just the right thing to do. It’s smart business. It’s how Hearthfire builds not just portfolios, but legacies. When we choose authenticity over polish, honest communication over perfect presentations, we create something more valuable than any single deal, we create lasting partnerships that compound returns for everyone involved.

The transparency advantage isn’t coming. It’s here. 

And it’s transforming how we build wealth, relationships, and lasting value.